
The Grassroots Institute, together with its partners, continues its work on strengthening local democracy, improving the legal framework of local self-government, and promoting effective mechanisms for public participation in the territorial communities of Zakarpattia Region. An important milestone has been achieved within the project “The Community Charter as an Instrument of Real Democracy”: the comprehensive legal audit of the local regulatory framework of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community, Berehove District, Zakarpattia Region, has been completed. The audit resulted in a systematic assessment of the community’s existing local regulatory acts and strategic documents, the identification of legal and institutional gaps, and the development of recommendations for preparing a new Community Charter and improving local governance mechanisms.
An important outcome was also the preparation of a Roadmap for the Development, Adoption, and Implementation of the Charter of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community, which outlines the sequence of legal, drafting, consultation, and organizational activities required for the next stages of the project. For the Grassroots Institute, this work represents another important step towards ensuring that community charters become not merely formal regulatory documents, but practical instruments for residents’ participation, transparent decision-making, accountable local government, and sustainable community development.
A territorial community charter plays an important role in the legal framework of local self-government in Ukraine. Its purpose extends beyond regulating individual aspects of community life. A well-developed Charter can establish clear procedures for public participation, define mechanisms of interaction between residents and local authorities, and reflect the historical, cultural, social, and institutional characteristics of a particular community. However, preparing such a document requires a thorough understanding of the existing local regulatory framework.
Over time, territorial communities adopt numerous decisions, regulations, procedures, and strategic documents governing different aspects of local governance. Some provisions may require updating following legislative amendments, while others may contain inconsistencies, overlaps, or gaps that complicate their practical application. A comprehensive legal audit helps identify these issues before drafting a new Charter. For the Kamianske community, the audit was designed to assess the current state of local regulation, identify areas requiring improvement, and establish a sound legal foundation for the preparation of a modern and practically effective Charter. The objective was not simply to review existing documents, but to develop a coherent understanding of how local regulations can better serve the community and its residents.
During the audit, the project expert team conducted a systematic examination of the local regulatory framework of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community. The analysis focused on the consistency of existing local acts with Ukrainian legislation, their internal coherence, and their capacity to support effective local self-government and democratic participation.
Particular attention was paid to the relationship between regulatory documents and the community’s strategic development priorities. This approach made it possible to examine local governance not as a collection of separate documents, but as an interconnected system of legal and institutional mechanisms. The audit considered whether existing regulations provide clear procedures, adequately define responsibilities, and create practical opportunities for residents to participate in matters of local importance. The findings formed the basis for recommendations aimed at improving the community’s local regulatory framework and determining the structure and priority provisions of the future Charter.
One of the central components of the audit was the assessment of existing mechanisms through which residents can participate in local decision-making. The expert team examined several important areas of local democracy, including public hearings, general assemblies of residents, local initiatives, electronic petitions, and public electronic consultations. These mechanisms are essential for ensuring that residents have opportunities to express their views, submit proposals, and participate in discussions concerning community development. However, the formal existence of participation procedures does not automatically guarantee their accessibility or effectiveness.
Their practical application depends on several factors, including the clarity of legal requirements, public awareness, the availability of information, and the willingness of local self-government bodies to maintain constructive dialogue with residents. The audit therefore considered not only the regulatory basis of public participation but also opportunities to make these mechanisms more understandable, accessible, and responsive to community needs.
Electronic petitions and online consultations can expand opportunities for residents to communicate with local authorities and participate in decision-making. At the same time, digital participation mechanisms must be designed with regard to the actual capabilities of community residents. Limited digital literacy, inadequate internet access, and the absence of suitable technical devices may create additional barriers, particularly for older persons and residents of rural settlements. For this reason, the recommendations emphasize the importance of combining digital participation with traditional forms of direct communication. Digital tools should complement existing democratic mechanisms rather than exclude residents who cannot use electronic services independently.
Another important component of the audit concerned public participation in local budgetary processes. The ability of residents to receive information about budgetary priorities, participate in consultations, and submit proposals contributes to transparency and accountability in the management of community resources. The legal audit examined opportunities to improve these processes and develop clearer mechanisms for public involvement. Particular importance was attached to distinguishing broader public participation in budgetary decision-making from individual mechanisms such as participatory budgeting. The objective is to encourage meaningful engagement in the discussion of budgetary priorities and the development of local policies, taking into account the powers and responsibilities established by Ukrainian legislation.
The legal audit also addressed the organization of local self-government and the interaction between local authorities and residents. Particular attention was paid to the activities of starostas, local government officials who play an important role in representing the interests of residents of settlements within territorial communities. In rural communities, where settlements may be geographically dispersed, effective communication between residents and local authorities is especially important. The analysis considered opportunities to improve local regulatory provisions relating to the organization of community governance, interaction with residents, transparency, reporting, and accountability. These matters are directly relevant to the future Charter, which should provide a coherent framework for local participation and governance while remaining consistent with national legislation.
An important feature of the audit was the combination of legal analysis with information obtained directly from community representatives. In particular, the expert team considered the findings of an interview with Natalia Kuzma, Deputy Head of the Kamianske Village Council responsible for the activities of its executive bodies and Coordinator of the Working Group for the Development of the Draft Community Charter.
The interview provided valuable insights into the current state of public participation, practical challenges in communication between local authorities and residents, and the community’s expectations regarding the future Charter. Natalia Kuzma highlighted several issues requiring attention, including relatively low participation in public hearings and online surveys, insufficient use of local initiatives and electronic petitions, and digital barriers affecting certain groups of residents. She also emphasized the importance of reflecting the historical and cultural characteristics of the settlements forming part of the Kamianske community. These observations were valuable for identifying areas in which legal provisions may need to be improved or supplemented. Combining legal expertise with the practical experience of local self-government representatives helps ensure that recommendations are not merely theoretically justified but also relevant to the needs of the community.
Following the analysis, the project team identified areas requiring further regulatory attention.
A key objective was to determine which issues should be addressed directly in the future Charter and which would be more appropriately regulated through separate local acts or supplementary procedures. This distinction is particularly important for maintaining a coherent system of local regulation. The Charter should provide a stable legal framework for community life and democratic participation, while more detailed procedures may be established through relevant local regulations, where appropriate. The recommendations therefore address the need to review existing acts, clarify individual provisions, eliminate inconsistencies, and develop additional documents necessary for the effective operation of the Charter. The proposed approach seeks to avoid unnecessary duplication while ensuring that residents and local officials can understand how the relevant procedures should function in practice.
Another important aspect of the audit was the integration of contemporary principles of inclusion, equality, accessibility, and non-discrimination into local governance. Effective local democracy requires meaningful opportunities for participation by different groups of residents. This includes young people, older persons, persons with disabilities, internally displaced persons, veterans and their families, representatives of national minorities, and others who may experience barriers to participation. The audit considered opportunities to improve local participation mechanisms so that they are more accessible and responsive to different needs.
Particular attention was paid to the potential development of advisory and consultative bodies, accessible public consultations, and communication mechanisms that encourage broader community involvement. An inclusive approach also requires consideration of physical and digital accessibility, the availability of understandable information, and appropriate opportunities for residents to express their views. For the Grassroots Institute, these principles are essential components of modern local governance. A Community Charter should help create conditions in which residents can participate in local decision-making regardless of their age, social status, disability, place of residence, or digital skills.
The audit also considered opportunities to integrate principles of environmental security, responsible natural resource management, and sustainable development into the local regulatory framework. For the Grassroots Institute, this area is particularly important given our organization’s work in environmental law, environmental education, natural resource protection, and community development. Territorial communities play an important role in addressing local environmental challenges, managing communal resources, developing infrastructure, and promoting environmentally responsible decision-making within their legal powers. The future Charter can contribute to these objectives by establishing principles of openness, public participation, and responsible governance in matters affecting the community’s environment and natural resources. Integrating environmental considerations into local governance is also relevant to Ukraine’s recovery and the development of resilient territorial communities. At the same time, such provisions must remain consistent with national legislation and the legally established competencies of local self-government bodies.
Based on the results of the legal audit, the expert team developed recommendations intended to guide the next stages of the project. The recommendations focus on four interconnected areas.
1. Developing a Modern Community Charter
The first priority is the preparation of a legally sound, logically structured, and practically applicable Charter reflecting the characteristics and needs of the Kamianske community.
Particular attention should be given to defining the document’s structure, content, and priority provisions. The Charter should establish clear and accessible mechanisms of public participation and contribute to transparent and accountable local governance.
2. Improving the Local Regulatory Framework
The second priority concerns the review and improvement of existing local regulations.
This may involve clarifying individual provisions, amending or repealing outdated acts, and preparing additional local documents where necessary. The objective is to establish a coherent regulatory framework that supports the effective implementation of the Community Charter.
3. Strengthening Local Democracy
The third priority is to improve the practical accessibility and effectiveness of mechanisms through which residents participate in local decision-making. This includes public hearings, general assemblies, local initiatives, electronic petitions, public consultations, and participation in local budgetary processes. The recommendations emphasize the importance of providing residents with clear information about these mechanisms and establishing understandable procedures for their use.
4. Integrating Contemporary Governance Principles
The fourth priority is to incorporate principles of open governance, inclusion, equality, environmental security, and sustainable development into the community’s local regulatory framework. These principles should contribute to the development of a more accessible, transparent, and responsive system of local self-government. Together, the recommendations provide a foundation for further legal drafting and institutional improvement.
One of the most important outcomes of the audit was the preparation of the Roadmap for the Development, Adoption, and Implementation of the Charter of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community. This document establishes a structured approach to the next stages of the process. The Roadmap outlines the sequence of legal, drafting, consultation, and organizational measures required to prepare the Charter, discuss its provisions with relevant stakeholders, proceed through the adoption process, and support its practical implementation. A particularly important feature is the recognition that preparing and adopting a Charter should not be treated as the final objective. The practical effectiveness of the document will depend on how its provisions are implemented, whether residents are informed about available participation mechanisms, and how consistently local self-government bodies apply the established procedures. For this reason, the Roadmap provides a framework for moving from legal analysis to concrete actions.
The next stage involves using the audit findings and recommendations to develop the structure and individual provisions of the future Charter. The drafting process should take into account Ukrainian legislation, the community’s local characteristics, and the practical needs identified through consultations and expert analysis.
Another important stage is the discussion of the draft Charter with community representatives and residents. Public engagement is essential because the Charter is intended to regulate matters directly affecting community life. Consultation procedures should provide meaningful opportunities to submit proposals, express concerns, and discuss relevant provisions.
Following the necessary drafting and consultation stages, the Charter must proceed through the applicable procedures for its consideration and adoption. However, practical implementation will require continued attention. Residents need to understand which mechanisms are available to them and how they can exercise their participation rights. Local self-government bodies must also ensure that the relevant procedures are applied in accordance with legislation and the Charter’s provisions. The Roadmap therefore links the legal preparation of the Charter with the practical conditions necessary for its effective use.
For the Grassroots Institute, participation in the legal audit of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community is part of our broader commitment to strengthening civil society, developing local democracy, and supporting effective territorial governance. Our organization contributes to the expert activities of the project, including legal analysis, the preparation of recommendations, and the development of approaches to improving local participation mechanisms. The organization’s Director, Dr. Olha Donets, and Associate Professor at the Department of Environmental Law of Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University, serves as Project Manager of “The Community Charter as an Instrument of Real Democracy” and coordinates the work of the project’s expert team. We believe that high-quality local regulations should be developed through a combination of professional legal expertise, practical experience, and meaningful engagement with local communities. It is particularly important to avoid treating community charters as standardized documents that can be transferred from one community to another without adaptation. Each territorial community has its own history, institutional characteristics, social structure, and development priorities. These characteristics should be carefully considered throughout the legal drafting process. Our objective is to contribute to the development of community charters that are legally sound, understandable to residents, and capable of supporting meaningful democratic participation.
The completion of the legal audit represents an important result of cooperation between the project experts and the Kamianske Village Council. Such work requires access to relevant local documents, constructive communication, and a shared understanding of the importance of improving local governance mechanisms. The Grassroots Institute sincerely thanks Mykhailo Stanynets, Head of the Kamianske Village Council, and Natalia Kuzma, Deputy Head of the Village Council and Coordinator of the Charter Development Working Group, for their openness to cooperation and constructive engagement throughout the process. We also express our gratitude to the members of the working group and the team of the Kamianske Village Council for their cooperation and contributions to the project. Special appreciation goes to our partner organization, Carpathian Agency Human Rights “VESTED”, and the entire expert team for their professional work and continued commitment to strengthening local democracy in Zakarpattia’s territorial communities.
The completion of the legal audit marks an important transition from assessing the existing local regulatory framework to developing practical legal solutions. The next stage will focus on preparing and discussing the provisions of the future Charter of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community. The recommendations developed during the audit, together with the Roadmap, will guide the expert team’s further work. Particular attention will be paid to ensuring consistency with Ukrainian legislation, reflecting the community’s specific characteristics, and developing accessible mechanisms for residents to participate in local decision-making. The involvement of community representatives and residents will remain an important part of this process. For the Grassroots Institute, the value of the project lies not only in the preparation of a new legal document but also in supporting a more open, participatory, and accountable model of local governance.
The completion of the legal audit of the Kamianske Rural Territorial Community represents an important milestone in the implementation of “The Community Charter as an Instrument of Real Democracy”. The community now has a comprehensive legal assessment, recommendations for improving its local regulatory framework, and a structured Roadmap for the development, adoption, and implementation of its future Charter. These results establish a foundation for further expert work and constructive dialogue between local authorities, residents, and project partners. We believe that a modern Community Charter should serve as a practical instrument for strengthening public participation, improving transparency and accountability, and supporting sustainable community development. Its effectiveness will depend not only on the quality of its legal provisions but also on the willingness of all stakeholders to ensure that these provisions work in practice. The Grassroots Institute will continue working with its partners and the Kamianske community to support the development of a legally sound, accessible, and effective Charter. Our shared goal is to ensure that local democracy becomes a meaningful part of everyday community life and that residents have real opportunities to participate in decisions shaping their community’s future.
The project “The Community Charter as an Instrument of Real Democracy” is implemented by Carpathian Agency Human Rights “VESTED”, jointly with the Faculty of Law of Uzhhorod National University, the Research Institute for Fundamental and Applied Studies of European Territorial Cooperation, and the Grassroots Institute, in partnership with the Uzhhorod and Irshava City Territorial Communities and the Kamianske and Zarichanske Rural Territorial Communities, with financial support from the International Renaissance Foundation.
This material represents the views of the authors and does not necessarily reflect the position of the International Renaissance Foundation.
For more information, contact Dr. Olga Donets, mail@tgi.org.ua